Skip to content
Cocktailary

Sour family1924

Scofflaw(スコッフロー)

Scofflaw served in a coupe glass
スコッフロー · 1920sCoupe · Shaken

Rye, dry vermouth, lemon, grenadine — Prohibition's insult in a glass.

01Recipe

Recommended recipe

House spec — an editorial spec drawing on the sourced versions below.

Ingredients and measures
IngredientMeasure
Rye whiskey45 ml
Dry vermouth30 ml
Fresh lemon juice15 ml
Grenadine15 ml
Orange bitters2 dash

Total volume (pre-dilution)

  1. 01

    Add all ingredients to a shaker with ice.

  2. 02

    Shake until chilled.

  3. 03

    Strain into a chilled coupe. Garnish.

Garnish — Lemon twist

02Taste profile

Sweetness
60Strong
Sourness*
67Strong
Bitterness
35Light
Fruitiness
45Moderate
Herbal*
28Light
Alcohol
58Moderate
Crisp
60Strong

Independent editorial scores, 0–100. *Estimated from the ingredient list — a profile sketch, not a verdict.

03History

The word 'scofflaw' won a Boston Herald contest for a term to shame secret drinkers; Harry's put it on the menu the same year — dry vermouth, lemon, grenadine, rye.

It tastes like a Manhattan someone slipped a sour into — the dry-vermouth heart stays stirred-adjacent while the lemon makes it dance.

Sources — MacElhone (1924) · Difford's Guide

04Recipe versions

Each version is shown exactly as recorded in its source — unverified claims are flagged.

Total volume (pre-dilution)
  • Harry's ABC of Mixing Cocktails

    Harry's ABC of Mixing Cocktails

    Harry MacElhone · 1924 · Book · unverified

    • ⅔ rye
    • ⅓ dry vermouth
    • Lemon juice
    • Grenadine
    • Orange bitters

    Shake, strain.

Pick 2 versions to compare — up to 3 on a wider screen

05Variations

06The map
SavedView saved